Director uses Twitter poll to ask DC fans about casting 'Nightwing' and it was kinda weird

Giving the casting director a lot to think about...
Original image replaced with Mashable logo
Original image has been replaced. Credit: Mashable

The former Boy Wonder needs your help, apparently.

It was announced not so long ago that a live-action Nightwing movie was in the works, with Lego Batman director Chris McKay at the helm.

For those of you unfamiliar with the project it is about the character of Dick Grayson -- the original Robin who eventually breaks away from Batman's frankly troubling habit of child endangerment to become his own superhero. You guessed it: Nightwing.

Recommended deals for you

Apple AirPods Pro 3 Noise Cancelling Heart Rate Wireless Earbuds — $179.00 (List Price $249.00)

Sony WH-1000XM5 Wireless Noise Canceling Headphones — $198.00 (List Price $399.99)

Ring Indoor Cam Plus 2K Wired Security Camera (2-Pack, White) — $59.98 (List Price $119.98)

Apple iPad 11" 128GB Wi-Fi Retina Tablet (Blue, 2025 Release) — $399.00 (List Price $449.00)

Ring 2nd Gen 2K Wired Video Doorbell With Chime (2026 Release) — $49.99 (List Price $114.98)

Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Plus Streaming Player With Remote (2025 Model) — $37.99 (List Price $69.99)

Apple Watch Series 12 (GPS, 42mm, S/M Black Sport Band) — $349.99 (List Price $399.00)

Blink Outdoor 4 1080p 3-Camera Kit With Sync Module Core + Doorbell   — $65.99 (List Price $259.98)

Products available for purchase through affiliate links. If you buy something through links on our site, Mashable may earn an affiliate commission.

The film's director Chris McKay delivered some news about the project on Twitter, followed by this slightly odd poll.

Okay, where to start...

Firstly these categories are not necessarily mutually exclusive. For example a "badass martial artist" can also play a character as "vulnerable and emotional". Slamming a drop-kick into someone's thorax does not mean you are an emotionally invulnerable ice-person. (No offence, Mr. Freeze).

The juxtaposition of "badass martial artist" and "recognizable movie star" also rings a little strange, but that could be in response to the fan black-lash against Danny Rand's lacklustre fighting skills in Marvel's Iron Fist series.

Then comes a question about the ethnicity of the actor, and whether it's important to fans that they're Romani.

The character Dick Grayson has Romani roots, something that DC comics has been keen to highlight in recent years.

The inclusion of this detail in McKay's casting poll is clearly an attempt to show awareness about the discussion around whitewashing in comic books and Hollywood.

However, asking fans to choose whether they want someone Romani as opposed to a "recognisable movie star" is perhaps a clumsy attempt to engage with the issue.

Some commenters picked up on the fact that these suggested categories do not exclude casting a Romani actor.

Plenty there for the casting director to mull over.

Topics Comics DC Comics

Mashable Potato

Recommended For You
'The Wrong Girls' director Dylan Meyer on giant squids, casting cats, and Kristen Stewart's secret side
 Los Angeles Premiere Of "The Chronology Of Water" LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA - JANUARY 08: (L-R) Kristen Stewart and Dylan Meyer attend the Los Angeles Premiere of "The Chronology Of Water" at 2220 Arts + Archive on January 08, 2026 in Los Angeles, California.

'Kinda chic' is everywhere. Here's what it means.
Collage of women using the 'kinda chic' Instagram and TikTok trend for their social media accounts.

'Weird Al' Yankovic's Tiny Desk Concert is an absolute treat
'Weird Al' Yankovic plays a set on Tiny Desk Concert with his band.

'House of the Dragon' director calls Ormund Hightower 'evil'
A man stands opposite a younger man, clasping his face with both hands.

Former Rockstar director calls 'GTA 6' leaks a 'nothing burger'
GTA VI website dislplayed on a screen and PlayStation DualSense controller

Trending on Mashable
NYT Connections hints today: Clues, answers for October 7, 2026
Connections game on a smartphone

NYT Strands hints, answers for October 7, 2026
A game being played on a smartphone.

Wordle today: Answer, hints for October 7, 2026
Wordle game on a smartphone

The 37 best Prime Day tech deals: We found deals under $25, but also $1,200 savings on OLED TVs
tech products on sale for october prime day 2026