17 costume fails that are scary for all the wrong reasons

These beautiful Halloween disasters are a total treat.
 By 
Andy Moser
 on 

Spooky season has finally returned. It's time for candy, cavities, and costumes.

Everyone wants a strong costume game for Halloween. While there are sure to be infinite stellar outfits this year, there will also be plenty at the other end of the spectrum — the kind that scare you for all the wrong reasons. The kind that will have hoards of crying children fleeing porches without a single Tootsie Roll at the sight of them. The kind that should be the result of one too many Hallows' Eve tequila shots but could actually be embarrassingly earnest cases of trial and error.

You may not live down crafting a wretchedly ghoulish costume, but it's a Halloween experience as traditional as trick-or-treating or horror movie marathons. And with that, let's raise our skeleton-hand chalices high in a solemn toast to all of our spectacular Halloween costume blunders of years past.


You May Also Like

Recommended deals for you

Apple AirPods Pro 3 Noise Cancelling Heart Rate Wireless Earbuds — $179.00 (List Price $249.00)

Ring Indoor Cam Plus 2K Wired Security Camera (2-Pack, White) — $99.99 (List Price $119.98)

Apple iPad 11" 128GB Wi-Fi Retina Tablet (Blue, 2025 Release) — $399.99 (List Price $449.00)

Apple Watch Series 12 (GPS, 42mm, S/M Black Sport Band) — $349.99 (List Price $399.00)

Sony WH-1000XM5 Wireless Noise Canceling Headphones (Midnight Blue) — $198.00 (List Price $248.00)

Products available for purchase through affiliate links. If you buy something through links on our site, Mashable may earn an affiliate commission.

1. Communication is key

2. There's a reason the "Midriff Wiggle" never made it to TV

3. If anyone was looking for a reference for their buttholes-with-eyes costume this year

4. As viscerally terrifying as this is, we encourage all attempts at homemade Gritty costumes

5. Monstrous cookie abomination

CARD ID: 463443, CARD TYPE: Imgur

6. 🎶 Beauty and What I See In The Corner Of My Room During Sleep Paralysis 🎶

7. Buzzed Lightyear

8. Cursedby

9. This Bert and Ernie duo is wholly upsetting

10. Gonna go out on a limb and say the cat was not feeling the spooky spirit

11. Judged the Yoda hat by its size, did you?

12. This is what happens when you cut corners

13. Holding up a cross to this... cotton candy?

14. Wack Panther

15. No trident for the Aquaman costume? Stick a fork in it

16. An animal? Or a pancreas with a face? You decide

17. Is BB-8 swallowing this dog?

Mashable Image
Andy Moser

Andy is a fellow on Mashable's Culture team. He graduated with a B.S. from the University of North Florida in 2018 and moved to New York to pursue journalism in culture and entertainment. He can (and will) talk for too long about Star Wars and movies in general. His fear of stinging insects and 80+ degree weather will keep him inside forever. He wishes he were shorter.

Mashable Potato

Recommended For You
'The Wrong Girls' director Dylan Meyer on giant squids, casting cats, and Kristen Stewart's secret side
 Los Angeles Premiere Of "The Chronology Of Water" LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA - JANUARY 08: (L-R) Kristen Stewart and Dylan Meyer attend the Los Angeles Premiere of "The Chronology Of Water" at 2220 Arts + Archive on January 08, 2026 in Los Angeles, California.

'The Wrong Girls' review: Kristen Stewart and Alia Shawkat shine in stoner buddy comedy
Kristen Stewart and Alia Shawkat co-star in "The Wrong Girls."

Krispy Kreme’s new Looney Tunes Halloween collection is here — how to get a free doughnut in costume
Krispy Kreme Looney Tunes Halloween doughnuts

'Primetime' review: Robert Pattinson makes Chris Hansen a scary clown
Robert Pattinson stars as Chris Hansen in "Primetime."

How this lesbian watering hole became the most (in)famous bar in the world
A group of people dancing under colorful lights in front of a go-go dancer cage.

More in Life



Bark and Crocs just launched plush 'socks and sandals' dog toys and matching leashes — where to buy yours
Bark x Crocs dog toys


Trending on Mashable
NYT Connections hints today: Clues, answers for October 8, 2026
Connections game on a smartphone

How can 'Ted Lasso' fix itself?
Tanya Reynolds, Jason Sudeikis, and Brendan Hunt in "Ted Lasso."

Hurricane Isaias: Track the storm’s path online
A path projection from Hurricane Isaias

NYT Strands hints, answers for October 8, 2026
A game being played on a smartphone.

NYT Connections hints today: Meanings for each word for Oct. 8, 2026
NYT Connections logo.