Errorbar layering #409

Activity

1. a6073758 commented on Oct 23, 2012

   

   a6073758

   on Oct 23, 2012

   More actions

   Does anyone know a workaround? I plot a lot of lines and afterwards I want to plot the error bars on top of them. This works for the upper and lower horizontal lines, but the vertical line is in the back.
   Is there a way of getting those line elements and changing their layer so that they appear on top of the rest?
2. a6073758 commented on Oct 23, 2012

   

   a6073758

   on Oct 23, 2012

   More actions

   Ok, I found the solution already. I plot all those lines which should appear in the background with the keyword zorder=1. That one did the trick.

   👍React with 👍2Reacted by Alex Miller and Nilanjan Banik
3. tacaswell commented on Jan 26, 2013

   

   tacaswell

   on Jan 26, 2013

   Member

   More actions

   @WeatherGod Is this fixed? Sorry to pester you.
4. pelson commented on Feb 15, 2013

   

   pelson

   on Feb 15, 2013

   Member

   More actions

   Nudge.
5. WeatherGod commented on Feb 15, 2013

   

   WeatherGod

   on Feb 15, 2013

   MemberAuthor

   More actions

   Thanks for the nudge. No, it isn't fixed. I modified one of the example scripts to demonstrate the issue.
   The linewidths and cap sizes are exaggerated in order to make the problem very visible.
   

   from math import pi
   from numpy import array, arange, sin
   import pylab as P
   
   fig = P.figure()
   x = arange(10.0)
   y = sin(arange(10.0)/20.0*pi)
   
   P.errorbar(x,y,yerr=0.5,capsize=10,linewidth=5)
   
   y = sin(arange(10.0)/20.0*pi) + 0.5
   P.errorbar(x,y,yerr=0.5, uplims=True, capsize=10, linewidth=5)
   
   y = sin(arange(10.0)/20.0*pi) + 0.75
   upperlimits = array([1,0]*5)
   lowerlimits = array([0,1]*5)
   P.errorbar(x, y, yerr=0.5, uplims=upperlimits, lolims=lowerlimits, capsize=10, linewidth=5)
   
   P.xlim(-1,10)
   P.show()
   
6. tacaswell commented on Feb 15, 2013

   

   tacaswell

   on Feb 15, 2013

   Member

   More actions

   
   The default zorder of lines and collections are still different (I think lines are 0, collections are 1 and line collections are 2). If you add explicit zorder arguments to this example it behaves properly.

   The answer may be that errorbar should have a finite default value of zorder instead of leaving it as None

   from math import pi
   from numpy import array, arange, sin
   import pylab as P
   
   fig = P.figure()
   x = arange(10.0)
   y = sin(arange(10.0)/20.0*pi)
   
   P.errorbar(x,y,yerr=0.5,capsize=10,linewidth=5, zorder=0)
   
   y = sin(arange(10.0)/20.0*pi) + 0.5
   P.errorbar(x,y,yerr=0.5, uplims=True, capsize=10, linewidth=5, zorder=1)
   
   y = sin(arange(10.0)/20.0*pi) + 0.75
   upperlimits = array([1,0]*5)
   lowerlimits = array([0,1]*5)
   P.errorbar(x, y, yerr=0.5, uplims=upperlimits, lolims=lowerlimits, capsize=10, linewidth=5, zorder=2)
   
   P.xlim(-1,10)
   P.show()
   
7. tacaswell commented on Jan 16, 2014

   

   tacaswell

   on Jan 16, 2014

   Member

   More actions

   note to self: set a default zorder for error bars
8. ghost assigned

   tacaswell

   on Jan 16, 2014
9. tacaswell commented on Jan 17, 2014

   

   tacaswell

   on Jan 17, 2014

   Member

   More actions

   This is actually a deeper issue than I first grasped.

   Because errorbar is drawn using a set of artists (Line2D and Collection objects) which get added to different lists inside the Axes object. The vertical lines are drawn using vlines which returns a LineCollection and the caps are drawn using plot which returns a Line2D object. In Axes.draw all of the artists are collected into a single list (collections first, then lines) and sorted by zorder, for a set of errorbar plots with the same zorder all of the caps will always be drawn after all of the bars are drawn.

   Short of re-writing how draw works or a major re-write of errorbar, this is not fixable.

   This is another case where having sematic high-level containers (see thread on mailing list about the D3 work) would be helpful.
10. tacaswell commented on Feb 1, 2014

    

    tacaswell

    on Feb 1, 2014

    Member

    More actions

    Removed the milestone and flagged and taagging as wontfix. To get the ordering correct, you need to explicitly set the z-order of each errorbar call.

    @WeatherGod If you agree, please close.
11. WeatherGod commented on Feb 3, 2014

    

    WeatherGod

    on Feb 3, 2014

    MemberAuthor

    More actions

    I agree that it would be hard to fix this problem. This is yet another reason for updating our rendering engine to utilize a DOM tree traversal rather than this layering approach.

    Maybe we should have a new tag "cantfix"?
12. tacaswell

    added

    cantfix

    and removed

    wontfix

    on Feb 3, 2014
13. tacaswell commented on Feb 3, 2014

    

    tacaswell

    on Feb 3, 2014

    Member

    More actions

    done
14. tacaswell

    closed this as completedon Feb 3, 2014