Executive read: No outcomes have reached accepted or rejected status; pending volume is concentrated in Issue Monster, Detection Analysis Report has a provisional underdefined signal, and stuck status cannot be established without previous-cycle history.
Legend:
🔴 Action Items
- Missing outcome reference: Repair PR Sous Chef's issue-number capture for the unknown create-issue outcome in the linked run; the evaluator reports “issue number not found.”
- Underdefined signal: Clarify acceptance/rejection criteria or provide a dedicated evaluator for Detection Analysis Report. Its current outcome is ignored with “no replies.” The label is provisional because repeated-cycle consistency cannot be checked.
- Lifecycle history: Restore cache-memory read/write capability to enable stuck classification, trend comparison, and persistence of this cycle's metrics.
- Waste and acceptance: No highest-waste workflows can be distinguished: all have no rejected outcomes. Acceptance quality cannot yet be assessed because there are no accepted or rejected items; the reported zero acceptance rate is a denominator-zero default, not evidence of poor quality.
- Aging and human effort: No pending items exceed the age threshold. There are no accepted items from which to assess zero-touch performance or a need for human edits.
- Ignored outputs and fallback quality: Review targeting or output type for Detection Analysis Report and Agent Job Health Monitor, whose workflow-level ignored shares exceed the threshold. Fleet-wide ignored share does not exceed it, and no existence-only fallback evaluations were reported.
Detailed metrics, evidence quality, workflow counts, and trends
Outcome Scorecard — 2026-10-10
| Metric |
Value |
Status |
| Acceptance rate |
0% reported; N/A (0 terminal items) |
— insufficient denominator |
| Zero-touch rate |
0% reported; N/A (0 accepted items) |
— insufficient denominator |
| Waste rate |
0% |
🟢 <10% |
| Median time to resolution |
— |
— |
| Accepted |
0 / 12 |
— |
| — strong evidence |
0 |
merged, completed, approved |
| — medium evidence |
0 |
engaged, retained |
| — weak evidence |
0 |
existence only |
| Rejected |
0 |
— |
| Ignored |
2 |
no observable follow-up |
| Unknown |
1 |
issue number not found |
| Zero-touch |
0 / 0 |
— |
| Pending |
9 |
— |
| Runs checked |
6 |
— |
The per-item evaluations reconcile the total: 9 pending + 2 ignored + 1 unknown = 12. The summary does not include an explicit unknown count. Fleet ignored share is 16.7%, below the 30% threshold.
Per-Workflow Breakdown
All waste rates are tied at 0%; alphabetical order breaks ties. Acceptance and zero-touch are undefined for every workflow because their denominators are zero; no workflow can meaningfully be flagged below 60% acceptance yet.
| Workflow |
Accepted |
Rejected |
Ignored |
Pending |
Acceptance |
Zero-touch |
| Agent Job Health Monitor |
0 |
0 |
1 |
1 |
— |
— |
| Daily Model Inventory Checker |
0 |
0 |
0 |
1 |
— |
— |
| Detection Analysis Report |
0 |
0 |
1 |
0 |
— |
— |
| Issue Monster |
0 |
0 |
0 |
6 |
— |
— |
| PR Sous Chef |
0 |
0 |
0 |
1 |
— |
— |
PR Sous Chef additionally has 1 unknown outcome. Ignored shares are 50% for Agent Job Health Monitor and 100% for Detection Analysis Report. All other workflows have 0% ignored outcomes.
Evidence Quality
Existence-only fallback evaluations: 0 / 12 (0%). No accepted evidence of any strength is present. Eleven evaluations have medium evidence strength; the unknown PR Sous Chef outcome has weak evidence. Evidence strength alone does not imply acceptance.
Lifecycle Evidence and Persistence
The oldest pending item is Issue Monster comment 6090982227, aged 3,051 seconds (50.85 minutes) at evaluation. No pending item exceeds 48 hours.
| Workflow |
Pending |
Unknown |
Ignored |
Total |
| Issue Monster |
6 |
0 |
0 |
6 |
| PR Sous Chef |
1 |
1 |
0 |
2 |
| Agent Job Health Monitor |
1 |
0 |
1 |
2 |
| Daily Model Inventory Checker |
1 |
0 |
0 |
1 |
| Detection Analysis Report |
0 |
0 |
1 |
1 |
Cache-memory read/write tools are unavailable. Previous-cycle counts and rates could not be read, and this cycle could not be saved to cache. No recurring stuck pattern or trend is asserted. Detection Analysis Report's provisional underdefined label reflects this cycle only; consistent ignored/unknown share above 50% remains unverified.
Status/reference validation passed for every row: matching token counts of 6, 2, 2, 1, and 1, with identical left-to-right status order. Outcome input order is preserved within each workflow. The unknown outcome links to its recorded run rather than an unavailable issue identifier.
📊 Measured by Outcome Collector · codex · gpt60 · 47.4 AIC · ⌖ 54.9 AIC · ⊞ 15K
Executive read: No outcomes have reached accepted or rejected status; pending volume is concentrated in Issue Monster, Detection Analysis Report has a provisional underdefined signal, and stuck status cannot be established without previous-cycle history.
Legend:
🔴 Action Items
Detailed metrics, evidence quality, workflow counts, and trends
Outcome Scorecard — 2026-10-10
The per-item evaluations reconcile the total: 9 pending + 2 ignored + 1 unknown = 12. The summary does not include an explicit unknown count. Fleet ignored share is 16.7%, below the 30% threshold.
Per-Workflow Breakdown
All waste rates are tied at 0%; alphabetical order breaks ties. Acceptance and zero-touch are undefined for every workflow because their denominators are zero; no workflow can meaningfully be flagged below 60% acceptance yet.
PR Sous Chef additionally has 1 unknown outcome. Ignored shares are 50% for Agent Job Health Monitor and 100% for Detection Analysis Report. All other workflows have 0% ignored outcomes.
Evidence Quality
Existence-only fallback evaluations: 0 / 12 (0%). No accepted evidence of any strength is present. Eleven evaluations have medium evidence strength; the unknown PR Sous Chef outcome has weak evidence. Evidence strength alone does not imply acceptance.
Lifecycle Evidence and Persistence
The oldest pending item is Issue Monster comment 6090982227, aged 3,051 seconds (50.85 minutes) at evaluation. No pending item exceeds 48 hours.
Cache-memory read/write tools are unavailable. Previous-cycle counts and rates could not be read, and this cycle could not be saved to cache. No recurring stuck pattern or trend is asserted. Detection Analysis Report's provisional underdefined label reflects this cycle only; consistent ignored/unknown share above 50% remains unverified.
Status/reference validation passed for every row: matching token counts of 6, 2, 2, 1, and 1, with identical left-to-right status order. Outcome input order is preserved within each workflow. The unknown outcome links to its recorded run rather than an unavailable issue identifier.